r/TheBoys Jul 04 '24

Both quotes taken verbatim from interviews Season 4

Post image
22.4k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

3.3k

u/fuwafuwa7chi Jul 04 '24

Source for the Starlight quote: ScreenRant

And the Hughie one: Variety

3.5k

u/Hitchfucker Jul 04 '24

I was kind of hoping the quote was take out of context but nope, he fully meant for the Hughie scene to be a joke.

It’s actually worse, the way he talked about Hughie’s breakdown made it seem it was mostly just about his dad and had nothing, or at least not too much to do with Tek Knight and Ashley. So the one supposedly tactful thing about that story arc wasn’t even there.

554

u/signeduptoaskshippin Jul 05 '24

All the people spamming "it wasn't supposed to be a joke" in shambles lmao

507

u/UnexpectedVader Jul 05 '24

It’s understandable, it’s such a twisted scene at the expense of the most morally good lead that it’s hard to believe the writers thought it would come across as a joke

But nope it’s just a case of them being weirdos

233

u/JAragon7 Jul 05 '24 edited Aug 15 '24

bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles

22

u/mauore11 Jul 05 '24

I get it. Having a guy go though that may seem funny and it is usually the trope. The thing is, it is very dark and if you do not light the scene as comedic it become hard to watch.

The breakdown was suposse to let you know that it was no joke for Hughie. The double standard ibecomes apparent and you feel bad for having laughed at it. Props to Jack for that breakdown, it may not have been scripted that way, but he showed how traumatizing it was.

44

u/JAragon7 Jul 05 '24 edited Aug 15 '24

bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles

11

u/mauore11 Jul 05 '24

I agree, It was shot comedically, it was Jacks breakdown what madre it real. Idk if it was intended, but I understood it was a comentary on double standard. If it was accidental, then props to Jack for that performance because it felt real.

32

u/JAragon7 Jul 05 '24 edited Aug 15 '24

bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles bungie bungles

-13

u/mauore11 Jul 05 '24

To be fair there's a lot of dark comedy. Sexual "accidents" or gory violence is expected. The effects from those things is what makes it interesting.

16

u/CenterInYourMother Jul 05 '24

Yeah but its not a commentary, the showrunners just genuinely thought it was funny

3

u/muffledmiss Jul 05 '24

They did a poor job of conveying the joke then. Like, where was the punchline?

-4

u/ElenaKoslowski Jul 05 '24

I had a great laugh. Maybe you guys are just too vanilla? There were far worse scenes in the past but a bit foot tickling breaks peoples mind. Not just the scenes were hilarious, reactions like this thread makes it even better. Like it's The Boys. What did you guys expect?

→ More replies (0)

3

u/HellBoyofFables Jul 05 '24

Even the breakdown is lame because it only references his dad and not the incredible fucked up sexual assault and torture he just experienced which would obviously contribute heavily to his breakdown but nope it’s just issues with his dad is the real problem and the whole ordeal is being treated as a joke

2

u/mauore11 Jul 05 '24

Him describing his experience is what triggers it. The "I miss my dad" is more a cry for help. It is not grief, it's a ptsd event.

1

u/HellBoyofFables Jul 05 '24

No he starts crying outside, starlight asks for him and then Hughie says he misses his dad, what happened to him is barely talked about at all and its not brought up when he’s breaking down

It was meant to be and treated as a joke

1

u/mauore11 Jul 05 '24

Watch the scene again.

1

u/HellBoyofFables Jul 05 '24

I did, the fact Hughie just got raped isn’t brought up and it’s the fact his dad died is the vocal point which is not appropriate at that moment considering the level of torture and sexual assault he just went through

→ More replies (0)

1

u/skida1986 Jul 05 '24

He’s an actor his breakdown after was intended. That was the point.

6

u/skida1986 Jul 05 '24

I was scared for him the whole scene, especially what happened to him the episode before. It definitely made Teks demise way more satisfying afterwards.

4

u/Its_Claire33 Jul 05 '24

Except they couched the trauma in his loss of his dad. They cheapened the effect it had on him and washed away how much it hurt and terrified him by pivoting to losing his father. They really cheapened the experience and that sucks because you don't get serious depiction of male survivors of sexual assault very often.

1

u/mauore11 Jul 05 '24

I agree it could have been deeper, but the trauma is there, the cry for help feels real, and to be honest, I'm glad he didn't "suck it up" because sadly it's what most male víctims are compelled to do. I'm interested on how the character deals with it from then on. Hopefully it's not just brushed aside or made into a joke.

2

u/Its_Claire33 Jul 05 '24

I just wish they didn't make the scene itself such a joke and then immediately make the fallout about his dad more than anything else.

2

u/mauore11 Jul 05 '24

Watch the scene. It reads very differently.

1

u/Its_Claire33 Jul 05 '24

I did watch it.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Alone-Worth-4166 Jul 05 '24

Go to a mental hospital id raping a guu "may seem funny" to you

-2

u/No_idea112 Jul 05 '24

Hughies real reaction to Tek knights shit was what made it so funny to me personally.

102

u/signeduptoaskshippin Jul 05 '24

At some point today I literally had 20 notifications from people spamming "it wasn't supposed to be a joke", I am fucking pleased that I am right, let me enjoy this moment ahahah

I have like 10+ replies I left that are downvoted to -10 and more of people coping that it wasn't supposed to be a joke

10

u/MyARhold30Shots Jul 05 '24

Me too bro, I was saying the scene was played for laughs and the writers made it a joke and my replies kept getting downvoted 😭🙏I hate Eric Kripke now but at least he’s shameless and proved me right

-16

u/Sepulchh Jul 05 '24

I am fucking pleased that I am right, let me enjoy this moment ahahah

You're happy that it was a joke?

Would you be sad if they had come out in the interview with something like "Oh yeah actually next episode will delve into how it affected him and the deep traumatic impact of the events will be processed seriously" ?

Did I misunderstand?

22

u/OLKv3 Jul 05 '24

It ain't that serious. He's happy that he was right and can rub it in the faces of people who talked to him like he was stupid for thinking they portrayed the scene as a joke.

6

u/Sepulchh Jul 05 '24

Oh right, cheers.

8

u/LastandBestHope1776 Soldier Boy Jul 05 '24

*misandrist ffy

7

u/Alone-Worth-4166 Jul 05 '24

Its understandable only for people that find male rape hilarious. Like kripke and rhe writera

6

u/blausommer Jul 05 '24

and 99% of reddit.

-2

u/PZbiatch Jul 05 '24

Come on, it’s not understandable. Lacking media literacy to think this wasn’t intended as a joke.